White gold vs Yellow Gold – Which is better?

White Gold vs. Yellow Gold

White gold and yellow gold are two of the most preferred metals for engagement rings. Some people prefer both, while others prefer to wear only one. We wanted to put together a complete comparison between the two so you can chose the best metal for you and your ring because this is such a crucial early step when designing and deciding on an engagement ring.

White and Yellow Gold’s History

The first examples of the purest type of gold used in jewelry date back to 4000 B.C., with the earliest examples hailing from ancient Mesopotamia and Egypt. Gold jewelry was widely prized as a symbol of riches and power by both men and women. It was a luxurious item that was frequently inlaid with beautifully colored stones. Throughout subsequent history, gold was valued as an adornment in every corner of the globe, with magnificent pieces of yellow gold jewelry from every major ancient civilisation to modern civilization occupying museums all over the world.

It was discovered that combining pure gold with other metals resulted in jewelry that was both stronger and more durable while also being less expensive. Until the invention of white gold in the 19th century, yellow gold ruled supreme. It wasn’t until the 1920s that white gold gained widespread popularity as a platinum alternative. The war effort necessitated the use of platinum for military machinery, and white gold has been popular ever since.

How Do They Get Made?

To grasp the fundamental difference between white gold and yellow gold, you must first understand how gold is manufactured. Gold is made up of 24 karats in any color. Gold is 24K gold in its purest form. Pure gold must be mixed with other metals to make it robust enough for everyday usage due to its malleability. This is why excellent jewelry is available in 10K, 14K, and 18K gold. The portions that aren’t made of gold are made of an alloy of copper, silver, palladium, and nickel.

Yellow gold does not require any additional components to change its hue; however, it does require additional alloys to boost its durability. You wouldn’t want 24K gold because it’s far too delicate to wear, and you won’t be able to locate it because it’s far too delicate to create.

To achieve its white tint, white gold often contains more metal alloys than yellow gold. White gold alloys including metals such as manganese, palladium, and nickel contribute to create white gold white-ish, just as copper alloys help to make rose gold pink. While nickel allergy isn’t a problem for everyone, many people with delicate skin are allergic to it and should avoid white gold unless it’s coated with rhodium. To be cautious, ask your jeweler choose a white gold ring produced entirely without nickel alloys if you’re allergic to nickel or suspect you might be.


Platinum is a highly durable metal that is often compared to gold in terms of strength. Platinum is the heaviest and densest metal on the planet. It’s worth noting, though, that while platinum is more powerful than gold, white gold is more powerful than yellow gold. White gold is more durable because it is alloyed with harder metals. To put it another way, additional metals must be added to white gold in order for it to be “white,” and one of the side effects of the additions is increased strength and durability.


While both contain elements of gold, yellow and white gold have different colors, which is likely the most significant variation between the two and will have the greatest impact on personal preference.

White gold resembles more silver than gold and has a white luster, whereas yellow gold is the color you think of when you think of gold. Yellow gold looks wonderful on practically everyone and with almost every stone style or hue. It’s inviting, warm, and timeless. White gold is similarly timeless, but it has a colder tone that contrasts well with all skin tones. Colorless diamonds, emeralds, and blue sapphires all look great with white gold engagement rings.

The hue of gold is affected by the quantity of gold karats present in the metal; the purer the gold is, the yellower it will be. The color of 18K gold, for example, will appear more yellowy-gold than 14K gold. If you want all of your jewelry to match, make sure it’s either all 18K yellow gold or all 14K yellow gold. While mixing and matching different colored metals is on-trend, you can always blend yellow gold and white gold jewelry for a trendy effect.

Maintenance and Durability

Yellow gold and white gold have different levels of durability, which is crucial to consider if you work with your hands or are physically active in a way that could damage your engagement ring.

Yellow gold is more prone to scratches and dents due to its high gold content. It may, however, be restored to its original brightness and beauty with frequent polishing and rebuffing. Your yellow gold engagement ring can also be resized at a later date if necessary, thanks to its flexibility.

Because of the presence of nickel and other metal alloys, white gold is slightly more durable than yellow gold. It does, however, require just as much, if not more, upkeep than yellow gold to keep its luster. White gold is frequently plated with rhodium to give it the brilliance you want in an engagement ring or any other piece of jewelry. This rhodium plating not only adds brilliance but also provides enhanced scratch and dent resistance. It does, however, fade off with time and must be replenished every few years. Most jewelers can redip white gold jewelry for free, so as long as you remember, it’s simple to keep it shiny and robust.

Expense & Budget

Understanding the costs of all the pieces is part of being an informed shopper, especially when it comes to jewelry and engagement rings. If you’re wondering if white gold or yellow gold is more expensive, the answer isn’t so simple.

Let’s go over the gold types again: 10K, 14K, and 18K. When it comes to gold, the variety, not the hue, is the most important factor in determining the price. The higher the gold concentration, the higher the price. 18K gold is the most expensive, whether you buy white gold or yellow gold. However, owing of the high gold content, it will be more susceptible to scratches and damage. You could want to go with 14K gold for better affordability and durability. There are plenty of budget-friendly settings and styles to pick from, whether you choose white or yellow gold. A 14K option in either precious metal will be of excellent quality and cost competitively.

White gold and yellow gold engagement rings are both fairly priced and commonly available when compared to engagement rings made of other metals. While white gold and yellow gold are more expensive than silver, they are of considerably superior quality. Furthermore, if you like the look of platinum, white gold is a similar-looking but much less expensive alternative.

The Pros and Cons of White and Yellow Gold

Pros of White Gold

  • A less expensive metal than its platinum sibling.
  • It has a really modern feel to it because it’s a popular metal for engagement rings.
  • White gold has a lovely silver-white gleam that complements any metal jewelry.
  • Because it is alloyed with harder metals, it is more robust and scratch resistant than yellow gold.
  • Goes well with diamonds and all colored gemstones because of their white color.
  • Cool-toned stones, such as colorless diamonds, emeralds, and blue sapphires, look great in white gold.
  • Looks great on all complexion tones, but especially fair or rosy ones.

Cons of White Gold

  • Every few years, it must be re-plated with rhodium to maintain its white hue and sparkle. Although it is a low-cost method, it still necessitates work.
  • It’s frequently combined with nickel, a metal that some people are allergic to.
  • To be hypoallergenic, it would need to be combined with alloy metals other than nickel.

Pros of Yellow Gold

  • Because gold was once the most popular metal for engagement rings, it exudes a retro and timeless vibe.
  • The purest kind of gold is 18K yellow gold. The purest gold color, the most hypoallergenic, and the easiest to maintain of all the golds.
  • Everyone looks beautiful in yellow gold.
  • Gives off a lovely warmth when used with diamonds of a lesser color grade.
  • Very flattering on all complexion tones, but notably olive and deeper skin tones.
  • Diamonds and warm-toned stones like ruby, morganite, and purple sapphire look great in yellow gold.

Cons of Yellow Gold

  • The least lasting and most expensive is 18K yellow gold.
  • Because it’s the most malleable gold, it’s more prone to dents and scratches, therefore it should be polished and cleaned on a regular basis.
  • Yellow gold variations are more difficult to match.
  • Under some situations, the metals in its alloy composition might tarnish or corrode, leaving a black stain on your finger. While it isn’t permanent and can be fixed, it can be inconvenient.

Leave a Comment